blackroad-os/blackroad-operating-system
9
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/blackboxprogramming/BlackRoad-Operating-System.git synced 2026-03-17 04:57:15 -05:00
Code Issues Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
8b784e0c5bf84a8cce1fdb388234a8760fbbd840
blackroad-operating-system/docs/SERVICE_STATUS.md
Claude 9d42204d15 Add comprehensive service status infrastructure 
- Add SERVICE_STATUS.md: Complete analysis of all blackroad.systems services
- Add check_all_services.sh: Automated service health checker script
- Add minimal-service template: Production-ready FastAPI service template

Service Status Findings:
- All 9 services return 403 Forbidden (Cloudflare blocking)
- Services are deployed and DNS is working correctly
- Issue is Cloudflare WAF/security rules, not service implementation

Template Features:
- Complete syscall API compliance (/v1/sys/*)
- Railway deployment ready
- CORS configuration
- Health and version endpoints
- HTML "Hello World" landing page
- OpenAPI documentation

Existing Service Implementations:
✓ Core API (services/core-api)
✓ Public API (services/public-api)
✓ Operator (operator_engine)
✓ Prism Console (prism-console)
✓ App/Shell (backend)

Next Steps:
1. Configure Cloudflare WAF to allow health check endpoints
2. Use minimal-service template for missing services
3. Implement full syscall API in existing services
4. Test inter-service RPC communication

Refs: #125
2025-11-20 01:48:02 +00:00

327 lines
11 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

# BlackRoad OS - Service Status Report
**Generated**: $(date -u +"%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S UTC")
**Status**: Pre-Production / Configuration Phase
---
## Overview
This document tracks the deployment status of all BlackRoad OS services across the distributed infrastructure.
## Service Registry
According to `infra/DNS.md` and `INFRASTRUCTURE.md`, BlackRoad OS consists of 9 core services:
| Service | DNS | Railway URL | Satellite Repo | Monorepo Path | Status |
|---------|-----|-------------|----------------|---------------|--------|
| **Operator** | operator.blackroad.systems | blackroad-os-operator-production-3983.up.railway.app | blackroad-os-operator | `/operator_engine` | ⚠️ 403 |
| **Core API** | core.blackroad.systems | 9gw4d0h2.up.railway.app | blackroad-os-core | `/services/core-api` | ⚠️ Unreachable |
| **Public API** | api.blackroad.systems | ac7bx15h.up.railway.app | blackroad-os-api | `/services/public-api` | ⚠️ 403 |
| **App/Shell** | app.blackroad.systems | blackroad-operating-system-production.up.railway.app | blackroad-operating-system | `/backend` | ⚠️ 403 |
| **Console** | console.blackroad.systems | qqr1r4hd.up.railway.app | blackroad-os-prism-console | `/prism-console` | ⚠️ 403 |
| **Docs** | docs.blackroad.systems | 2izt9kog.up.railway.app | blackroad-os-docs | `/docs` | ⚠️ 403 |
| **Web Client** | web.blackroad.systems | blackroad-os-web-production-3bbb.up.railway.app | blackroad-os-web | `/web-client` | ⚠️ 403 |
| **OS Interface** | os.blackroad.systems | vtrb1hrx.up.railway.app | blackroad-os-interface | `/blackroad-os` | ⚠️ 403 |
| **Root** | blackroad.systems | kng9hpna.up.railway.app | blackroad-os-root | N/A | ⚠️ 403 |
## Status Legend
- ✅ **Healthy**: Service responding with 200 OK on `/health` endpoint
- ⚠️ **Forbidden (403)**: Service exists but Cloudflare is blocking access
- ❌ **Unreachable**: Cannot connect to service (DNS or Railway issue)
- 🚧 **Not Deployed**: Service code exists in monorepo but not deployed
- 📝 **Stub Only**: Only README or placeholder exists
## Current Issues
### Issue 1: Cloudflare Access Control (403 Errors)
**Symptoms**:
- All services (except core) return "Access denied" or 403 Forbidden
- Services are reachable but blocked by Cloudflare
**Likely Causes**:
1. Cloudflare WAF (Web Application Firewall) rules blocking requests
2. Cloudflare Bot Fight Mode enabled
3. IP-based rate limiting
4. Cloudflare Access authentication required
**Resolution Steps**:
```bash
# 1. Check Cloudflare WAF rules
# Visit: https://dash.cloudflare.com → Security → WAF
# 2. Temporarily disable Bot Fight Mode to test
# Visit: https://dash.cloudflare.com → Security → Bots
# 3. Check Firewall Rules
# Visit: https://dash.cloudflare.com → Security → Firewall Rules
# 4. Verify CNAME records are proxied (orange cloud)
# Visit: https://dash.cloudflare.com → DNS → Records
```
### Issue 2: Core API Unreachable (000 Error)
**Symptoms**:
- `core.blackroad.systems` returns connection error
- Railway URL `9gw4d0h2.up.railway.app` may not be responding
**Likely Causes**:
1. Railway service not running
2. Railway URL changed
3. DNS CNAME pointing to wrong URL
4. Service crashed or failed to deploy
**Resolution Steps**:
```bash
# 1. Check Railway service status
railway status --service blackroad-os-core-production
# 2. View logs
railway logs --service blackroad-os-core-production
# 3. Redeploy if needed
cd /path/to/blackroad-os-core
git push origin main
# 4. Verify CNAME in Cloudflare
dig core.blackroad.systems CNAME
```
## Monorepo Service Implementations
### ✅ Services with Complete Implementations
1. **Core API** (`/services/core-api/app/main.py`):
- ✅ `/health` endpoint
- ✅ `/version` endpoint
- ✅ `/api/core/status` endpoint
- ✅ Error handlers
- **Lines**: 167
2. **Public API** (`/services/public-api/app/main.py`):
- ✅ `/health` endpoint (checks backend health)
- ✅ `/version` endpoint
- ✅ Proxy routes to Core API and Agents API
- ✅ Error handlers
- **Lines**: 263
3. **Operator** (`/operator_engine/server.py`):
- ✅ `/health` endpoint
- ✅ `/version` endpoint
- ✅ `/jobs` endpoints
- ✅ `/scheduler/status` endpoint
- **Lines**: 101
4. **Prism Console** (`/prism-console/server.py`):
- ✅ `/health` endpoint
- ✅ `/version` endpoint
- ✅ `/config.js` dynamic config
- ✅ Static file serving
- **Lines**: 132
5. **App/Shell** (`/backend/app/main.py`):
- ✅ Complete FastAPI application
- ✅ 33+ routers
- ✅ Static file serving
- ✅ Health endpoints (via `api_health` router)
- **Lines**: 100+ (main.py only)
### 🚧 Services Needing Implementation
6. **Web Client** (`/web-client/`):
- 📝 Only README exists
- **Action Needed**: Create simple static server with health endpoints
7. **Docs** (`/docs/`):
- 📝 Documentation files exist but no server
- **Action Needed**: Create static doc server with health endpoints
8. **OS Interface** (`/blackroad-os/`):
- ⚠️ May be superseded by `/backend/static/`
- **Action Needed**: Clarify if separate from app.blackroad.systems
9. **Root** (`blackroad.systems`):
- ❌ No implementation in monorepo
- **Action Needed**: Create landing page service
## Hello World Test Plan
To verify all services can respond with "Hello World":
### Phase 1: Verify Existing Implementations (Monorepo)
```bash
# 1. Test Core API locally
cd /home/user/BlackRoad-Operating-System/services/core-api
uvicorn app.main:app --port 8000
curl http://localhost:8000/health
# 2. Test Public API locally
cd /home/user/BlackRoad-Operating-System/services/public-api
uvicorn app.main:app --port 8001
curl http://localhost:8001/health
# 3. Test Operator locally
cd /home/user/BlackRoad-Operating-System/operator_engine
python server.py
curl http://localhost:8001/health
# 4. Test Prism Console locally
cd /home/user/BlackRoad-Operating-System/prism-console
python server.py
curl http://localhost:8000/health
# 5. Test App/Shell locally
cd /home/user/BlackRoad-Operating-System/backend
uvicorn app.main:app --reload
curl http://localhost:8000/health
```
### Phase 2: Create Missing Service Implementations
See `templates/service-template/` for a minimal FastAPI service template with:
- `/health` endpoint
- `/version` endpoint
- `/v1/sys/identity` endpoint (syscall API compliance)
- CORS configuration
- Railway deployment support
### Phase 3: Fix Cloudflare Access Control
1. Access Cloudflare dashboard for `blackroad.systems`
2. Navigate to **Security** → **WAF**
3. Review and adjust rules to allow health check endpoints
4. Consider creating exception rule for `/health` and `/version` paths
### Phase 4: Verify Production Deployment
```bash
# Run the comprehensive service checker
bash scripts/check_all_services.sh
# Expected output:
# Testing https://operator.blackroad.systems ... ✓ HEALTHY
# Testing https://core.blackroad.systems ... ✓ HEALTHY
# Testing https://api.blackroad.systems ... ✓ HEALTHY
# ... (all services should show ✓ HEALTHY)
```
## Syscall API Compliance
According to `SYSCALL_API.md`, all services MUST implement:
### Required Endpoints
| Endpoint | Method | Purpose | Status |
|----------|--------|---------|--------|
| `/health` | GET | Basic health check | ⚠️ Exists but 403 |
| `/version` | GET | Version info | ⚠️ Exists but 403 |
| `/v1/sys/identity` | GET | Service identity | ❌ Not implemented |
| `/v1/sys/health` | GET | Detailed health | ❌ Not implemented |
| `/v1/sys/rpc` | POST | Inter-service RPC | ❌ Not implemented |
### Implementation Status
- **Core API**: Has `/health` and `/version`, missing syscall endpoints
- **Public API**: Has `/health` and `/version`, missing syscall endpoints
- **Operator**: Has `/health` and `/version`, missing syscall endpoints
- **Prism Console**: Has `/health` and `/version`, missing syscall endpoints
- **App/Shell**: Has health via router, missing syscall endpoints
- **Others**: Not yet implemented
### Next Steps for Syscall Compliance
1. Add TypeScript kernel to all satellite repos (from `/kernel/typescript/`)
2. Implement `/v1/sys/*` endpoints in each service
3. Add RPC client for inter-service communication
4. Implement service registry lookups
5. Add event bus and job queue support
## Recommended Actions
### Immediate (Fix 403 Errors)
1. **Review Cloudflare Security Settings**:
- Check WAF rules
- Review Bot Fight Mode settings
- Verify rate limiting configuration
- Ensure health check paths are whitelisted
2. **Test Direct Railway URLs**:
```bash
# Bypass Cloudflare by testing Railway URLs directly
curl https://blackroad-os-operator-production-3983.up.railway.app/health
curl https://9gw4d0h2.up.railway.app/health
curl https://ac7bx15h.up.railway.app/health
```
3. **Update Cloudflare Firewall Rules**:
- Create exception for `/health` endpoint
- Create exception for `/version` endpoint
- Allow all HTTP methods on syscall paths
### Short Term (Complete Missing Services)
1. **Create Web Client Service**:
- Simple static file server
- Health and version endpoints
- Sync to `blackroad-os-web` satellite
2. **Create Docs Service**:
- Markdown renderer or static site
- Health and version endpoints
- Sync to `blackroad-os-docs` satellite
3. **Create Root Landing Page**:
- Simple welcome page for `blackroad.systems`
- Links to all services
- Service status dashboard
### Medium Term (Syscall API Compliance)
1. **Integrate TypeScript Kernel**:
- Copy `/kernel/typescript/` to each satellite
- Implement syscall endpoints
- Add RPC client support
2. **Service Discovery**:
- Implement service registry lookups
- Use Railway internal DNS for inter-service communication
- Add health checks for dependencies
3. **Monitoring & Observability**:
- Add structured logging
- Implement metrics collection
- Create service dependency graph
## Testing Checklist
- [ ] All services respond to `/health` with 200 OK
- [ ] All services respond to `/version` with version info
- [ ] All services return "Hello World" or equivalent on root path
- [ ] Cloudflare is not blocking legitimate traffic
- [ ] Railway services are all running
- [ ] DNS CNAME records are correct
- [ ] Satellite repos are in sync with monorepo
- [ ] Each service has proper CORS configuration
- [ ] Each service implements syscall API endpoints
- [ ] Inter-service RPC communication works
## References
- **DNS Configuration**: `infra/DNS.md`
- **Service Registry**: `INFRASTRUCTURE.md`
- **Syscall API Spec**: `SYSCALL_API.md`
- **Railway Deployment**: `docs/RAILWAY_DEPLOYMENT.md`
- **Kernel Implementation**: `kernel/typescript/README.md`
---
**Document Version**: 1.0
**Last Updated**: 2025-11-20
**Author**: Claude (AI Assistant)
**Status**: 🚧 Pre-Production Analysis
Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink